Steel vs. Graphite Shafts: Which is Better?
Steel vs. Graphite Shafts: Which is Better?

Posted on March 25, 2022

With any amount of time spent on the course, you're likely to have thought about the difference between steel and graphite shafts. Depending on your particular swing, you'll respond differently to this question. Nevertheless, finding out what shaft works best for you might make all the difference in your performance.

Monark Golf has provided a helpful guide for those unfamiliar with the differences between graphite and steel shafts. So please keep reading to discover its benefits, downsides, and what shaft best fits your swing! 


Steel Shafts

Steel shafts are designed for amateur golfers and advanced players for two reasons: 

1. First, better golfers have faster swings than novices, so they don't require the extra aid graphite shafts provide.

2. The main reasons are the grip, accuracy, and ability to manipulate the ball. Steel shafts may work the ball better than graphite shafts. Hence better players frequently upgrade to steel shafts.


Graphite Shafts

Graphite shafts are used in almost every driver because they are lighter and can improve clubhead speed. Thus, these clubs contain graphite shafts to compensate for their lack of swing speed (steel shafts are rare in senior and women's golf clubs). Beginner golfers should use graphite shafts since they are more forgiving and do not hurt when mishit.


Steel Shaft VS. Graphite Shaft: Factors to Consider

Img src: https://www.canva.com/photos/MAC8SWnATQE-man-s-golf-shoes-and-golf-club/

The key considerations to evaluate while choosing the shaft material are mentioned and explained below.


Golfers Skill Level

The skill level or expertise counts greatly when choosing graphite or steel shafts. Graphite shafts are ideal for beginners who need more practice.

It's because graphite shafts are lighter and faster. On the other hand, the steel shaft provides superior stability and decreased swing speed for players who suffer from the excessive swing speed.

Technically, graphite shafts are better for beginners, recreational, and handicappers, whereas steel shafts are preferable for skilled and experienced players.


Grip Feel

Steel shafts provide a harsher feel because they are heavy, stiff, and less flexible. Graphite shafts provide a better feel than steel shafts because they are lighter, less stiff, and more flexible.


Shaft Flex

Golf shafts are available in graphite and steel flexes. The extra stiff shaft is at the ultimate stiffness end, while the senior and lady's shafts are more flexible.

The tricky issue about golf club flex is that it varies across manufacturers. A Fujikura Stiff shaft is not a True Temper stiff. That's why customized club fitting has grown in popularity.

A steel shaft will often play stiffer than a graphite shaft. Other elements like weight and kick point have an impact. So be prepared to adjust flexes when switching from graphite to steel golf shafts; the flex of your club should match your swing speed (More speed means a stiffer golf shaft)


Ball Flight

The type of golf shaft you choose will affect the flight of your golf ball. Graphite shafts fly higher, whereas steel shafts fly lower and are more regulated.

High launches lead to greater carry and longer shots. The main issue with greater ball flight is that it might be difficult to manage for players with quick swing speeds.

Thus, too high an angle and too much vertical launch might cause a loss of distance and control. Due to this, several mid to high handicap golfers have trouble launching the ball. Without this launch, bullets tend to go into the green, making precision difficult. 

So if you're a golfer who likes to manipulate ball flight and hit high and low shots, steel golf shafts are an excellent choice.


Wedges, Putter, and Iron

The kind of shaft matters a lot regarding wedges, putters, and irons. Steel shafts provide a superior feel for wedges than graphite ones. It is the way to go unless you're searching for a cheap option with wedges.

On the other hand, putters with steel shafts favor the superior feel. Due to this, it is preferable to use graphite shafts in Irons rather than iron shafts. Irons' faster swing speed is mostly due to the usage of graphite shafts.


Steel VS. Graphite: What's Best For You?


Img src: https://www.canva.com/photos/MAESC1GM1As-golf-clubs-on-the-grass/

Bear in mind that there is no such thing as a "correct" golf shaft. When you consider the variety of golf shafts offered by each manufacturer, it's clear that there is a lot of equipment available.
Therefore, do not be afraid to experiment with different shaft materials and specifications; it may significantly improve your game. Most importantly, understanding the differences between graphite and steel puts you in a far better position to make this choice. Visit us at Monark Golf and get the best golf club shaft today!